I loved "If I stay" but only liked "Where she went". While many readers had trouble with Mia in this book, for me Adam was the one that made me frustrated. I didn't like that he had become such a stereotype music star (sleeping with countless women, Hollywood girlfriend, addiction), that he stayed so passive in the important parts of his life. I wanted more of him, in contrast I understood that Mia had to act the way she did to stay sane and to deal with the situation. In the end I couldn't really believe that Adam could change his life overnight without any major issues (for example withdrawl symptoms).